The following CZMA consistency-appeal decision documents are provided by NOAA’s Office of General Counsel, Oceans and Coasts Section, for public access and information. The documents include decisions to override the state’s objection, not to override the state’s objection, to override the state’s objection on procedural grounds, and to dismiss the appeal. The documents below do not include appeals that were withdrawn or settled (see the Appeals Spreadsheet).
|
Appellant
|
State
|
Appeal Filed
|
Decision Date
|
| Norwalk Cove Marina, Inc.
|
NY |
5/19/2021 |
1/25/2022 |
| Jordan Cove Energy Project
|
OR |
3/20/2020 |
2/8/2021 |
| Electric Boat Corp.
|
NY |
1/24/2020 |
11/16/2020 |
WesternGeco G&G VACATED
(Court Order to Dismiss and Vacate 9/20/21)
|
NC |
9/20/2019 |
6/15/2020 |
| WesternGeco G&G
|
SC |
9/20/2019 |
6/15/2020 |
| Cangrejos Yacht Club
|
PR |
1/2/2014 |
9/16/2014 |
| Mark Smolinski
|
NY |
8/13/2013 |
4/14/2014 |
| Pan American Grain Co.
|
PR |
1/27/2010 |
12/1/2010 |
| Consistency Appeal of Broadwater Energy LLC and Broadwater Pipeline LLC
|
NY |
6/6/2008 |
4/13/2009 |
| Foothill/Eastern Transportation Corridor Agency
|
CA |
2/15/2008 |
12/18/2008 |
| G. Walter Swain
|
DE |
1/31/2008 |
9/24/2008 |
| Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC, and Mill River Pipeline, LLC
|
MA |
8/27/2007 |
6/26/2008 |
| AES Sparrows Point LNG, LLC, and Mid-Atlantic Express, LLC
|
MD |
8/8/2007 |
6/26/2008 |
| Donald & Susan Williams
|
NY |
7/5/2007 |
8/29/2007 |
| Prescott Ammarell
|
NY |
7/28/2006 |
11/3/2006 |
| Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC
|
RI |
6/26/2006 |
7/24/2006 |
| Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC
|
RI |
-- |
10/10/2005 |
| Fernando Otero Rodriguez
|
PR |
2/03/2005 |
2/03/2005 |
| Edwin Irizarry Garcia
|
PR |
6/15/2004 |
1/26/2006 |
| Villa Marina Yacht Harbour, Inc.
|
PR |
10/31/2003 |
2/3/2006 |
| Islander East Pipeline Co., LLC
|
CT |
11/14/2002 |
5/5/2004 |
| Walter Taylor
|
MI |
11/11/2002 |
1/3/2003 |
| Millennium Pipeline Co., L.P.
|
NY |
6/7/2002 |
12/12/2003 |
| Peter & Nancy Fenner
|
NY |
9/6/2001 |
8/1/2005 |
| Barnes Nursery, Inc.
|
OH |
7/10/2001 |
12/23/2003 |
| U.S. Erie Island Development Co.
|
OH |
2/8/2001 |
10/22/2004 |
| Jade Venture Group, LLC
|
MI |
12/7/2000 |
11/15/2001 |
| Singleton Development Corp.
|
MS |
9/29/2000 |
5/16/2005 |
| Collier Resources Co.
|
FL |
4/3/2000 |
4/17/2002 |
| Filiberto S. Montalvo Durand
|
PR |
2/17/2000 |
10/25/2000 |
| Alfonzo Cruz Colon
|
PR |
2/7/2000 |
7/11/2000 |
| John T. Keegan
|
PR |
10/26/1999 |
12/5/2003 |
| Ricardo Ramirez
|
PR |
5/6/1999 |
7/20/2000 |
| Fernando Otero Rodriguez
|
PR |
4/21/1999 |
2/3/2005 |
| Pedro Vidal
|
PR |
4/21/1999 |
12/29/2004 |
| Jorge Torres-Martinez
|
PR |
4/15/1999 |
3/26/2003 |
| Luz Torres DeRosa |
PR |
4/14/1999 |
2/3/2005 |
| Carlos Frontera Colley
|
PR |
4/6/1999 |
10/29/2004 |
| Rick Bellew
|
AL |
11/17/1997 |
7/23/1999 |
| G. Marvin Kuffskie
|
AL |
12/16/1996 |
3/26/1997 |
| Jessie W. Taylor (reissued from earlier case with changes)
|
SC |
continued |
12/28/1998 |
| Jessie W. Taylor
|
SC |
4/10/1996 |
12/28/1998 |
| D'Olive Joint Venture
|
AL |
9/22/1994 |
1/24/1995 |
| Vieques Marine Laboratories
|
PR |
4/29/1994 |
5/28/1996 |
| Joseph M. Mattone
|
NY |
3/2/1994 |
6/19/1997 |
| Jesse Floyd
|
SC |
1/7/1993 |
6/10/1993 |
| Olga Velez Lugo
|
PR |
7/9/1992 |
9/9/1994 |
| ERA
|
PR |
5/13/1992 |
11/29/1994 |
| Mobil Exploration & Producing U.S., Inc.
|
FL |
4/29/1992 |
6/20/1995 |
| Virginia Electric and Power Co.
|
NC |
10/3/1991 |
5/19/1994 |
| Carlos A. Cruz Colon
|
PR |
8/26/1991 |
9/27/1993 |
| Chevron U.S.A., Inc.
|
FL |
3/27/1991 |
1/8/1993 |
| Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc. (continuation of earlier cases)
|
NC |
continued |
12/8/1999 |
| Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc.
|
NC |
12/3/1990 |
9/2/1994 |
| Robert E. Harris
|
NY |
10/26/1990 |
12/2/1992 |
| Yeamans Hall Club
|
SC |
9/25/1990 |
8/1/1992 |
| Davis Heniford
|
SC |
9/24/1990 |
5/21/1992 |
| Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc.
|
NC |
7/31/1990 |
9/2/1994 |
| Claire Pappas
|
NY |
3/13/1990 |
10/26/1992 |
| Eugene J. Dean
|
MA |
-- |
1/24/1992 |
| Roger W. Fuller
|
NC |
12/7/1989 |
10/2/1992 |
| Henry Crosby
|
SC |
10/17/1989 |
12/29/1992 |
| Shickrey Anton
|
SC |
10/2/1989 |
5/21/1991 |
| Jose R. Perez-Villamil
|
PR |
8/16/1989 |
11/20/1991 |
| A. Elwood Chestnut
|
SC |
8/14/1989 |
11/4/1992 |
| Amoco Production Co.
|
AK |
4/3/1989 |
7/20/1990 |
| Jorge L. Guerrero-Calderon
|
PR |
3/17/1989 |
5/5/1993 |
| International Paper Realty Corp.
|
SC |
2/2/1989 |
7/17/1990 |
| Mobil Exploration & Producing U.S., Inc.
|
FL |
1/11/1989 |
1/7/1993 |
| Union Exploration Partners, Ltd. with Texaco. Inc.
|
FL |
12/21/1988 |
1/7/1993 |
| The Asocicion de Propietarios de Los Indios, Inc.
|
PR |
9/26/1988 |
2/19/1992 |
| Michael P. Galgano
|
NY |
7/14/1988 |
10/29/1990 |
| Chevron U.S.A., Inc.
|
CA |
7/5/1988 |
10/29/1990 |
| Texaco, Inc.
|
CA |
3/23/1988 |
5/10/1989 |
| Sucesion Albeto Bachman
|
PR |
3/18/1988 |
10/10/1991 |
| Exxon Co., U.S.A.
|
NY |
1/7/1987 |
6/14/1989 |
| John K. Delyser
|
NY |
1/6/1987 |
2/26/1988 |
| The Korea Drilling Co., Ltd.
|
CA |
12/15/1986 |
1/19/1989 |
| Long Island Lighting Co.
|
NY |
11/19/1986 |
2/26/1988 |
| John Bianci
|
NY |
9/5/1985 |
1/25/1989 |
| Gulf Oil Corp.
|
CA |
3/13/1985 |
12/23/1985 |
| Southern Pacific Transportation Co.
|
CA |
10/23/1984 |
9/24/1985 |
| Exxon Co., U.S.A.
|
CA |
3/9/1984 |
11/14/1984 |
| Union Oil Co. of California
|
CA |
12/12/1983 |
11/9/1984 |
| Ford S. Worthy, Jr.
|
NC |
8/5/1983 |
5/9/1984 |
| Exxon Co., U.S.A.
|
CA |
7/22/1983 |
2/18/1984 |
| Daspit |
MS |
-- |
1988 |
|
|
|
|
